Solving today’s sports television optics problem

I was traveling across the Southwest a few years ago and stopped into a cafe on the outskirts of a small, dusty town.  The cafe was rustic and peculiar in a farm-house kinda way.  You know — sorta quaint; sorta homely.

I was famished from not eating all day and I was eager for the waitress, who was equally rustic and peculiar, to bring food.

Until – – –

I experienced one of those moments when we see something we wish we hadn’t; something we can’t un-see no matter how much we wish we could.

It happened when the waitress emerged from the kitchen to deliver food to a table nearby.  What followed was a cockroach that scurried behind her just fast enough to escape the crunch of a swinging kitchen door.

Cockroaches are bad.  Cockroaches in cafes are worse.  Cockroaches falling from plates are abhorrent.

I called to the waitress and explained what I had seen and for her to cancel my order.  She was polite and apologetic and she explained that the cafe didn’t have a cockroach problem.  “We’re inspected and we always pass.  We’ve never had a cockroach anywhere near our food,” she said.

But, I couldn’t un-see that cockroach nor un-think that it might have been on that plate.  I left.

So, what does that have to do with sports?

Some time ago, I sat down to watch a sporting event. As the program began, there was music and the voices of broadcasters over the brilliant network logos.  Everything seemed normal.

Until – – –

The sight of the broadcasters themselves were shown.  Neither was at the game. Instead, it appeared they were covering the game from their homes.  I had never heard of such a thing and the word “heresy” came to mind.  What made them any better than me to tell me what was happening if they were sitting at home just like me?

In time I reasoned that they had probably interviewed players and coaches during the week and had analytic assistants during the game.  It was  scant supposition but enough to keep me tuned in.

However, as I looked closer, things got worse and that’s where the “un-see” factor kicked in.

The play-by-play announcer was enclosed in a space so small that it very well might have been a closet.  I suppose that shouldn’t have been terribly off-setting but it does seem curious and unprofessional, unless your name is Marv Alberts.

The game analyst was in a larger space that appeared to be a personal library.  It had godawful yellow walls and a bookshelf that was laden with the self-applause of abundant trophies, plaques, and the like.  Actually, I was okay with that visual.  I was less okay with the occassional sounds of squealing children.  I love children but I’m less-enamored with the suspicion that between camera shots, my professional game analyst is also a Cheetos-crunching babysitter.

It’s fair to say that those broadcasters would rather have been at the game and that they were just following orders of the network.  And, I must admit that had I closed my eyes for the entirety of the broadcast, I wouldn’t have known the difference.  But, it’s hard to watch a game with your eyes closed.

Maybe I’m being overly critical here, but it seems to me that optics are important.  I mean, we’re talking television, not radio.  Even after watching several games with at-home broadcasters, it still bothers me and I wonder how many fans have been disturbed by it as well.

I suspect there are many like me and if so, then the networks need to help us out here.  Doing so wouldn’t be hard because there already is one very simple solution:


Many of us have used Zoom to keep in touch with others and we know how easy it is to impose a backdrop over our surroundings to make it appear we are someplace else.

I don’t want networks to lie about where their broadcasters are, but it would be helpful if they supplied their broadcasters with network backdrops to increase the appearance of professionalism.

It’s a feature that can be imposed with absolutely no cost and is so simple that even a non-techy broadcaster can do it.

And if they can’t, then I have a nine year old grandson who can.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s